Parental Alienation Deposition Questions

In divorce law, parent alienation happens when one parent turns their children against the other parent.

The parent engaging in parent alienation is referred to as the alienating parent, and the parent against whom such behavior is directed is called the target parent.

Experts have described parental alienation as a form of psychological manipulation and child abuse. Its impact can profoundly harm the child’s emotional and mental well-being for years to come.

In legal battles, especially in child custody matters, it’s extremely important to identify and put a stop to parental alienation as soon as possible. Many times, this will require taking legal action.

In family law cases, taking the alienating spouse’s deposition is the most effective litigation tool for obtaining valuable testimony and determining the depth and prevalence of parental alienation.

This article offers an in-depth look at the type of deposition questions divorce and family lawyers ask to prove parental alienation.

An added benefit is that the target parent can gain a deeper insight into the suffering of their children and the legal options the target parent can take to end the abuse.

Here are some key topics we cover in this article:

• What is parent alienation and the type of emotional damage it can cause
• The value of deposition testimony in parental alienation cases
• The types of deposition questions to ask of the offending parent
• Misconceptions and fears related to parental alienation

Understanding parental alienation

Parental alienation is when the alienating parent knowingly works to damage the child’s relationship with the target parent.

Parental alienation often begins with disparaging comments about the other parent, limiting contact, or creating a false sense of loyalty towards the alienating parent.

The goal is to damage the child’s relationship with the other parent.

Statistic: Despite the prevalence of parental alienation, only 10-15% of cases receive intervention through therapy or court orders. This low rate highlights a gap in support for affected children and parents

Psychological harm

The alienating parent’s tactics can be subtle or overt. However, the desired impact is always the same: to damage or destroy the parental bond between the child and the alienated parent. And sometimes, the emotional and psychological damage to the child is permanent.

The emotional and psychological effects on the child can include:

• Children may exhibit symptoms of escalating stress, anxiety, or depression resulting from being caught between the child’s conflicting loyalties or the loss of a supportive parental relationship.
• Children may experience identity problems, as they may feel pressured to reject a part of their own identity that was closely tied to the alienated parent.
• In severe cases, the child may exhibit symptoms not unlike post-traumatic stress due to the ongoing conflict and emotional manipulation involved in parental alienation.
• The child might experience cognitive dissonance, where they struggle to reconcile the negative portrayal of one parent with their own experiences of that parent, leading to confusion and emotional pain.

Statistic: Approximately 13% of U.S. parents report experiencing parental alienation behaviors, impacting an estimated 22 million parents. And Around 30% of children involved in parental alienation cases exhibit symptoms such as anxiety, depression, and low self-esteem, effects that can persist into adulthood, significantly impacting their mental health and relationships​

The Legal Option

In severe cases, the most effective option the targeted parent can take in stopping the other parent’s harmful and abusive behavior is to consult with a divorce or family law attorney and explore their legal options, such as modifying child custody arrangements or seeking court orders that prohibit alienating behaviors.

Most family law courts are familiar with the problem of parent alienation and the potential for psychological and emotional damage the alienating parent can cause to the children and the targeted parent.

If the court determines it is in the best interests of the child, the court will take action to protect the child from such abuse.

Proving Parental Alienation Through the Deposition Process

The deposition of the alienating parent

The main goal of the family law deposition in child alienation cases is to obtain evidence and information, clarify facts, and assess the parent’s credibility.

What are depositions?

Depositions usually take place in the deposing attorney’s conference room.

The participants at the deposition include the deponent, attorneys for both parties, and a court reporter who will transcribe the proceedings.

The deposing attorney will ask the deponent about the facts and issues surrounding the alleged parent alienation and relevant biographical questions.

Lying during a deposition can result in penalties, including charges of perjury.

The opposing attorney may object to specific deposition questions based on legal grounds such as the attorney-client privilege. However, the deponent must answer the deposing lawyer’s questions truthfully and without objection.

Common deposition topic areas in parental alienation cases:

• Child’s Behavioral Changes
• Parental Communications
• Parenting Decisions and Interactions

Parent Alienation Deposition Questions

Questions About The Child’s Behavioral Changes

The deposing lawyer will want to know if there were any significant changes in how the child feels or acts towards the alienated parent at or near the time of the parent’s separation or divorce.

• Can you describe the current relationship you have with your children?

• Can you describe the current relationship the children have with the other parent?

• How would you describe your child’s relationship with the other parent before and after your separation?

• Have you observed any reluctance or anxiety in your child about spending time with the other parent? If so, describe and explain them.

• Can you recall any specific event after which you noticed a change in your child’s attitude towards the other parent? If so, describe and explain them.

• What reasons does your child give for not wanting to visit or talk to the other parent? If so, describe and explain them.

• Can you describe the custody battles you had with your former spouse?

• Have there been any changes in your child’s behavior or demeanor immediately following visits with the other parent? If so, describe and explain them.

• How does your child describe their visits with the other parent when they return home? If so, describe and explain them.

• Has your child ever expressed fear or discomfort about visiting the other parent? Describe them and the related circumstances.

• Do you know of any situations where your child received gifts or favors in exchange for expressing dislike or refusing to visit the other parent? If so, describe and explain them.

• Have you noticed your child using language or expressions about the other parent that seem uncharacteristic for their age? If so, describe and explain them.

• Does your child exhibit signs of guilt or confusion after interacting with the other parent? If so, describe and explain them.

Watch Utah Family Law Attorney Kelly Peterson Discuss Methods of Proving Parent Alienation:

Questions About Parental Communications

The deposing lawyer will want to know how the alienating parent talks about the other parent in front of the child since it shapes how the child sees them.

• Have you ever spoken with your children about how the other parent has hurt them? What did you tell them?

• Do you remember the first time you explained to the children why you were getting divorced? Who was there, and what was said about the reasons for the divorce?

• Have you ever told the children not to call or contact the other parent? Can you explain the reasons and circumstances?

• Have you ever talked about your divorce to your parents, siblings, or good friends about your divorce – were any of the children present during these conversations?

• Have you ever made disparaging remarks to family members about the other spouse – Did you ever ask your parents not to speak badly about the spouse?

• When speaking to your children, did you ever refer to the other parent by their first name?

• Did you ever give your child a cell phone but not share the number with the other parent?

• What have the children told you about the other parent while in the other parent’s custody?

• Have you ever told your children negative things or warnings about your spouse? Can you provide specific examples?

• How do you discuss the other parent with your child? Can you provide specific phrases or words you’ve used?

• Have there been instances where you criticized the other parent in front of your child? If so, please give the details.

• Do you involve your child in disputes between you and the other parent? If so, describe and explain.

• How do you react when your child brings up the other parent in conversation? If so, describe and explain.

• Can you describe any discussions in which the child might have overheard negative comments about the other parent, such as other family members? If so, please give the details.

• What is your response when your child asks about the reasons for your separation or divorce?

• Do you ever monitor the communications between the child and the other parent? If so, please give examples.

• How do you handle situations where your child receives misinformation about the other parent from external sources? If so, please give the details.

• Are there any rules or restrictions you’ve set about what your child can tell the other parent about your household? If so, please give the details.

Questions About Parenting Decisions and Interactions

The deposing lawyer will want to know about the choices made by the alienating parent that might have created a gap between the child and the other parent. These might include changes to visitation schedules and keeping the child away from school or extracurricular activities.

• When was the last time you co-parented with the children, such as attending a school event in which your child was involved?

• Did you and the other parent draft a co-parenting plan?

• Have you ever made significant decisions about the child without consulting the other parent? Please explain these instances.

• Have you encouraged your child to maintain a healthy relationship with the other parent? If so, please give the details.

• Have there been occasions where you denied the other parent access to school events, medical appointments, or social activities involving your child? If so, please give the details.

• Have you ever discussed your custody disputes or legal strategies with your child? What was the context?

• In what ways have you supported or hindered your child’s communication with the other parent via phone, text, or email? If so, please give the details.

• Have there been changes to your child’s living arrangements that could impact their relationship with the other parent? Describe these changes.

• What steps have you taken to ensure your child feels safe and supported when discussing both parents? If so, please give the details.

Misconceptions About Parental Alienation

Misconception: Parental alienation can be proven in court.

Reality: Proving parental alienation is hard and requires documentation, expert testimony, and a full custodial investigation. Sometimes a private investigator will help lead you to evidence that will support your claim of parent alienation and lead the court to order a mental evaluation of the children and parents. Sometimes the psychological evaluation will lead to an expert opinion that one or both parents have narcissistic tendencies or other mental health disorders that would explain the dynamics of parental alienation behavior in the case.

Misconception: Going to court will fix the parental alienation.

Reality: Even with court intervention the psychological effects of parental alienation can linger and require ongoing therapy and support for the child.

Fears Related to Parental Alienation

Fear That The court won’t take parental alienation seriously.

Reality: Courts are now more aware of the seriousness of parental alienation especially when supported by evidence and expert testimony.

Fear That Going to court will make things worse.

Reality: While court battles can be stressful, going to court is often necessary to protect the child’s well-being and future relationship with both parents.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the Signs of Parental Alienation?

Recognizing signs of parental alienation is crucial for timely intervention. Key indicators include negative language about the other parent, lack of interest in spending time with them, refusal to communicate, inconsistent narratives about the other parent, and unfounded accusations.

Awareness of these signs can help address the situation effectively and prioritize the child’s emotional well-being in custody arrangements.

Q. What are the signs of parental alienation that can be explored during depositions?

A. Look for inconsistencies in the child’s feelings and statements about the other parent, reluctance to spend time with the parent, or parroting the alienating parent’s language.

Q. What role do mental health professionals play in these depositions?

A. Mental health professionals assess the child’s emotional well-being and the psychological impacts of parental behaviors. Their expert testimony can help identify signs of alienation and guide custody decisions.

Balance and Fairness: It is crucial to approach allegations of parental alienation with neutrality and an evidence-based perspective. Jumping to conclusions can lead to further harm and injustice.

Bottom Line

Parental alienation affects how children relate to both parents, raising important questions about behavior, communication, and parenting choices.

We have learned how crucial it is to be aware of alienating parents’ tactics, such as manipulation and setting up communication barriers that result in the children’s needs and voices not being heard during the legal or therapeutic process.

Asking the right questions in depositions can help pinpoint alienating behaviors that might affect your child’s emotional health.

Tackling parental alienation effectively is key to protecting the well-being of the children who have been caught, at no fault of their own, in the confusing and conflicting child custody battles that take place between the parents.

Sources and References:

Law Office of Kelly Peterson

WebMD

Psychology Today

Family Law Matters – Ca.

Related Articles and Helpful Services…